Question:
What makes "Anti-Semitism" different than any other form of racism or bigotry?
2012-04-22 17:24:29 UTC
Why is hatred toward Jews different than that of hatred toward Arabs or hatred toward Blacks or hatred toward Pakistanis?

Judging from this article on Wikipedia which clearly has either been written by a Zionist or pro-Zionist, one could be lead to believe that racism toward Jews was the only form of racism that ever existed or exists: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Semitism

Also, what makes hatred toward Jews different than that of hatred toward the Chinese or Japanese?
Seventeen answers:
DAN DAN
2012-04-25 02:00:03 UTC
It should be the same. No difference
?
2016-05-17 12:57:44 UTC
Making fun of someones religion isn't racism, but it is bullying and smallminded. A lot of atheists that seem to have a problem with their self-esteem come here only to insult those that believe in a particular religion, which is bascially bullying. Apparently, either a lot of atheists have some very deep insecurity problems which results in their need to bully, or they're just ignorant. I suppose its a pretty fair mix of both. Strange though, the agnostics aren't usually like that, just the really rabid atheists. I guess rabid atheists are in the same category as fundies, huh?
?
2012-04-24 18:43:27 UTC
I must say that I also find Anti-Semetism quite odd. For racism against other groups like blacks and Latinos they can provide tons of evidence to support their opinions that these groups are inferior.



Anti-Semetism appears to be simple jealousy though as Jews are among the most intelligent people in the world iin addition to their great success in business.
2012-04-22 23:04:50 UTC
Yes this word wants a ( License to Kill)....



Whenever there is a latest, prior or future savagery from ISRAELIS something has GREAT TIMING appears with strategic motive the word (ANTI-SEMITISM) helps against all critics that suggest ISRAELI motive is cruel and any more discussions about ISRAEL is taboo.......



Look at the US, geopolitically, diplomatically, militarily and financially current conditions SUCK and our special relationship with ISRAEL cost us 700 BILLION dollars on this misled war....



These PEOPLE are Russian, Ukrainien, German and polish you cant trace them back to there ancestry anymore there genes are mixed genetically with the residents of Poland and the residents of all Europe also what isn’t true is that all Jews are of Semitic descent....



Look at this forum on ISRAEL, I see people ask about mixing with Jewish people every day or entering Jewish faith with completely no genetic relationship to Jews to receive some-kind of offer that Israeli law has......



Everyday people are not aware of this issue...
BMCR
2012-04-22 19:56:27 UTC
And how do you know that the "Wikipedia" article was "clearly" written by a Zionist and how does someone's political views invalidate what the person wrote there?



Maybe you can cite some examples that you then argue are incorrect.



You are also making a false distinction between what you term "anti-Judaism and anti-Semitism". The dictionary defines anti-Semitism as:

"hatred of Jews; unfair treatment of Jews"

http://oald8.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/dictionary/anti-semitism

It does not make a distinction of the reasons for WHY the hater may supply to "justify" their hatred.

Thus, if the hatred, bias, or prejudice of Jews is religiously motivated, racially motivated, class motivated, or simply "the anti semite couldn't think up a reason to excuse his hatred", it can be labeled "anti-Semitism".



In fact, I have SEEN anti semites try to argue they are not anti-Semitic because they were not "anti Judaism" and have seen them argue the opposite.
Kevin7
2012-04-22 18:41:55 UTC
Jews have suffered some of the worst atrocities on Earth in terms of human rights in such incidents such as the Pogroms and the Holocaust.Antisemitism was a term coined by 19 th century non-Jewish writer Wilhelm Marr,he meant only Jews even though Arabs and Other groups are also Semites
?
2012-04-22 17:48:17 UTC
Its not different Only the Jews of the world hate any kind of criticism labeling it anti semitic while blacks, Pakistanis , Japanese etc tend to ignore any offensive remarks.
2012-04-22 17:45:10 UTC
Anti-Semetism is specifically hatred towards Jews. Its different because we the Jews have been criticized for the bubonic plague(s) (more than 1), The Crusades, Both World Wars, The Holocaust, Being to rich (This is somewhat true, im a Jew myself but Jews are very smart for example Albert Einstein), and many things after that.
?
2012-04-22 17:27:36 UTC
Nothing is different, its not racism since it is a religion not a race. The only difference is that 6 million Jews got killed in WWII for being Jewish, it makes the whole thing a much more touchy situation since there have been huge real consequences from antisemitism in recent history.
Jim Gatz
2012-04-22 17:26:46 UTC
It isn't, you answered yourself. Unless you want to find it's different and you're here looking for reasons to be rasist towards Jews.
Dominic
2012-04-22 17:26:37 UTC
beacuse no 1 likes them
affinity292
2012-04-22 20:59:38 UTC
Silly troll. Tricks are for kids.



1. Jews ARE a race.



2. So, you believe that the wikipedia page about anti-semitism focuses too much about Jews.



Is there a drum roll coming?



Is this the part where I say, "gosh. I was just reading the wikipage on Islamaphobia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamophobia

and you'd think that Islamaphobia is the only hatred out there.



Oh right, it's a wikipage ON Islamaphobia. And the other page is a page ON Anti-semitism.
Snail
2012-04-22 17:41:07 UTC
wow your mind should be really distorted if you can't see it.



6 milion jews were murdered for being jews. no such action was taken to any other types of racism.
2012-04-23 04:50:55 UTC
It's an ignorant term.



Just stick with DISCRIMINATION.



===



Even better: "unjust social discrimination"; there, if the discriminator thinks they are truthful they can prove to us that it is "just social discrimination". Fair's fair.



===



Social Discrimination (n.)

1.(MeSH)A preconceived judgment made without adequate evidence and not easily alterable by presentation of contrary evidence.



===



Just discriminations:



A - Jewish culture is based on an unfounded premise i.e. God.



B - This delusion of the Jewish culture led to the formation Christianity and Islam.



C - These in turn led to the unjust social discrimination against Jewish culture.

- But IRONICALLY were it not for this DELUSION it would never have occurred.

- The delusion came back to bite the Jewish culture.



D - These thus destroyed most of the world's cultures leaving only MONOTHEISM.

- except some Eastern religions like HINDUISM.



E - Judaism is an oblivious plagiarism from ZOROASTRIANISM, EGYPTIAN RELIGIONS, BRAHMANISM (Abraham).



F -. Were it not for the existence of Israel the many bloody conflicts would never have occurred.

-.Islam was caused by the God delusion; Jews started it, and thus are punching themselves in the face.
?
2012-04-22 20:02:59 UTC
In many ways it's not. However, there are some distinct differences:



(Taken from the works of Dr. Gustavo Perednik)



1. It is one of the oldest and longest running forms of racism as it still continues to this day.



2. It is universal and has existed in practically every country on earth, regardless of whether or not Jews lived there and how many Jews lived there if any.



3. It is permanent. Long after Jews were dispelled from various countries, the hatred persisted.



4. It goes deeper. The negative stereotypes are embedded in each culture. "over many centuries, millions of people believed either that the Jews transmitted leprosy, or poisoned wells to kill Christians, or used human blood for their rituals, or killed God, or have a world conspiracy, or constitute a promiscuous race, or are demoniac creatures, or, or, or...."



5. It's obsessive. "For the Judeophobe, Jews are not an enemy. They are the enemy. He does not speak of Jews; he speaks of the Jews. When Adolf Hitler gave his farewell speech to the German nation from his Berlin bunker where he committed suicide on April 30, 1945, what type of message did he convey? He did not remind his listeners of the glories of Germany, nor did he mention any regrets regarding the bloodiest of wars that he brought upon Europe -he stressed that the Jews had not been totally defeated and therefore implored that the Germans continue the struggle against their “eternal enemy.’’ Although Hitler is Judeophobia in its most extreme expression, Judeophobes share that obsession about the allegedly all-inclusive villainy of the Jews."



6. It's more dangerous. "With appalling ease this particular hatred transforms into physical violence. In most countries in which they lived, at some point in history, Jews were killed for being Jews."



7. It's based on fantasy. "Jews can be hated for having eaten non-Jews in the past, or for dominating the world in the present; for having killed God or for being the source of war, slavery or evil, or for fabricating the Holocaust."



Some Well-Known Consequences of antiSemitism:



Holocaust

Pogroms

Crusades

Inquisitions



But these are only the most famous incidents. There have been books written about this stuff. The list goes on and on. In many cases, entire Jewish neighborhoods were destroyed. In other cases, Jews were massacred, being the scapegoat for whatever terrible thing was happening at that time and place, such as being responsible for the plague or economic demise.



And to answer what you wrote to The King, anti-Judaism and anti-Semitism are both directed at the same people, thus resulting in the same devastating effects and therefore are interchangeable.



Nowadays antiZionism is the new form of antiSemitism. And there continue to be conspiracy theories directed at Jews. There continue to be racial stereotypes, wrongful blaming, Holocaust denial, and simply hatred just for the sake of it. Many people hate Jews without ever having met one.



@Salaam: Jews could just convert to Christianity?! You're in denial because you're an antiSemite yourself! Why do you keep obsessively posting question after question about this? It's because you hate Jews, and you want to paint a picture of us as a bunch of whiners who complain over nothing. Well, that's simply not true. When millions upon millions of people have been murdered over this hatred, it is indeed something worth mentioning.
John E
2012-04-23 08:05:57 UTC
The fact that our Jewish friends are not hated fore their olive-coloured/black beautiful skin complexion, something that would be described as racism, but for their religion.



Greetings
Billy Joe Jim Bob
2012-04-23 06:49:45 UTC
As far as I know the word antisemitism was coined by Zionists not Jews I was told by a Jew that Zionists are atheists anyways, and have nothing to do with Judaism anyways.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...